Castile is an old name. A bar of soap made only from olive oil, lye and water, with no other oil. The formula is so simple that every property of the bar can be read from a single fatty acid table. This piece records the classic Castile formula, the numbers behind it, and why a bar made only of olive needs a longer cure than any other formula.
Castile · a name more than five hundred years old
The story usually told begins in the Levant. Soap makers in Aleppo had long made hard bars from olive oil and laurel oil. When the craft spread to the northern shore of the Mediterranean, laurel oil was harder to obtain, so it was dropped and only olive oil was kept. Historians have still not agreed on the exact route by which the craft reached Spain.
The name comes from the Crown of Castile, where this soap was made on a large scale and shipped across Europe. According to John Hunt in a short history of soap published in 1999, the alkali used there was barilla, a crude soda from the ash of salt tolerant plants, boiled with local olive oil instead of animal fat. The result was a hard white bar, called jabón de Castilla, which grew harder with age while keeping its colour.
English writing mentions Castile soap from the 1430s, and imports through Antwerp appear in the London port books of the 1560s. Today the word Castile is used more loosely: many products with that name also contain coconut or other oils. This piece uses the narrowest and oldest sense, a bar made with olive oil alone.
One oil, one oleic column
The fatty acid table on the library's vegetable oils page gives extra virgin olive oil 65 to 80 percent oleic, 5 to 15 percent linoleic and 14 to 18 percent saturated fatty acids. Oleic acid has one double bond. During saponification, NaOH cleaves each triglyceride into glycerin and three sodium salts of fatty acids; in a Castile bar, most of those salts are sodium oleate.
A common misunderstanding is that the long oleic chain makes the bar hard. The opposite is true. The bend at the double bond keeps oleic chains from packing tightly, so the library records that olive gives a soft, conditioning bar that traces slowly. The hardness of a soap usually comes from straight saturated chains such as palmitic and stearic, as the piece on sweet almond oil compared through the same table.
Compared with coconut, the difference lies in lauric acid. The library records that lauric, a saturated fatty acid with 12 carbons, is what gives coconut oil its strong lather when saponified. A Castile bar has almost no lauric acid, so its lather is sparse and fine, and the feeling of cleansing is milder. Soap makers also note that a bar made entirely of coconut oil needs a long cure to become less harsh on the skin.
Lê Mai's Olive Artisanal Soap No.104 leans this way but is not a pure Castile: olive oil makes up more than 70 percent of the formula, with neem oil, shea butter and cocoa butter making up the rest. Those butters add saturated chains to the bar, exactly what a bar made only of olive lacks.
Lye ratio and saponification
The library gives the SAP value of olive oil with NaOH as about 0.135, meaning one gram of oil needs about 0.135 grams of NaOH to saponify fully. The figure is lower than coconut, about 0.190, because the oleic chain is longer than the lauric chain: the same weight of oil holds fewer triglyceride molecules, so it needs less alkali.
For 1,000 grams of olive oil, the calculation without any excess oil gives about 135 grams of NaOH. Superfat is set at 5 to 8 percent, meaning alkali is deliberately reduced so that part of the oil does not react. At 5 percent the NaOH comes to about 128 grams, at 8 percent about 124 grams. The two figures are the two ends of one formula: a higher superfat gives a milder bar, but a slightly softer one with more excess oil to oxidise. The library also reminds that every batch should be recalculated with a SAP calculator.
Distilled water for the lye solution is 280 to 300 grams, a water to alkali ratio of about 2.2 to 2.4 to 1. The excess oil left by the superfat is unreacted oil, mostly still in triglyceride form, not free oleic acid. It is spread through the bar, makes the bar milder in use, and is also the part that can slowly oxidise over the months of curing.
Cold mixing at 32 to 35°C
Olive oil is already liquid at room temperature and needs no melting. This differs from formulas with coconut, shea butter or cocoa butter, which have to be melted and then left to cool. A pot of liquid oil alone allows work at a low temperature from the very start.
NaOH releases strong heat as it dissolves in water. A chemical supplier's guide records that a concentrated solution can exceed 93°C while mixing, close to the boiling point of water. This is why lye is always added to water, never water to lye, and the jug is set in a well ventilated place. The solution is left to cool naturally to 32 to 35°C, the same temperature as the oil, then poured slowly into the oil and blended with a stick blender.
Castile reaches trace more slowly than other formulas. It takes five to eight minutes of blending to reach light trace, then a few more minutes to reach medium trace, with no need to go thicker. The reason is again the oleic column: a batter rich in saturated fat thickens quickly, while a base of almost entirely liquid oil needs time. Soap makers note that Castile rarely reaches a very thick trace.
Cutting after 48 hours
The batter is poured into a wooden mould lined with parchment paper and wrapped lightly for insulation, not too warm. Castile saponifies more slowly than multi oil formulas, and its gel phase is gentle and prolonged. Because the block stays soft for a long time, many ingredient suppliers reduce the water in a Castile recipe so the bar can be unmoulded sooner; the formula here keeps the stated amount of water and makes up for it with time.
The mould is left for 48 hours instead of the usual 24. After 48 hours, the bar is firm enough to unmould and cut with a wire cutter. It is still moist but holds its shape. Each bar is 2.5 to 3 centimetres thick and weighs 110 to 130 grams when freshly cut.
The surface is pale yellow, not the chalky white of bars heavy in coconut oil. The colour comes from the olive oil itself: the library distinguishes extra virgin olive, green and rich in polyphenols, used for skin and for Castile, from the mild or pomace grades commonly used for soap. Whichever grade is chosen, the bar carries its colour and scent.
A cure of four to six months
Castile needs the longest cure of all cold process formulas. One craft guide writes that recipes with more than 60 percent olive should cure at the long end of the four to six week range, while Castile needs at least six weeks and is better at six months to a year. One ingredient supplier recommends about a year for the best lather and notes that without enough cure the lather is very dense and feels slimy.
During those months, most of what happens is water leaving. The same guide quotes the chemist Kevin Dunn: the crystal structure of soap forms mainly in the first hours and days; during curing, the spaces between crystals narrow as water evaporates, while the crystals themselves change very little. A Castile bar loses water slowly, so it hardens slowly and its lather changes slowly too.
pH is often used as a measure of curing, but it changes less than people think. A 2025 study of ten handmade soaps measured pH from 9.10 to 10.51; soap is a salt of weak fatty acids and a strong alkali, so it stays slightly alkaline after curing. What a long cure changes most clearly is hardness and the feel of the lather: the bar becomes less soft, the lather less slimy, and the bar dissolves more slowly on the soap dish. A Castile cured long enough still gives a sparse, fine lather, true to its oleic column.
Castile is an exercise in patience. One oil. One bar. Four to six months.
There is no shortcut. Each month, a little more water leaves.
What remains is a bar that can be read from a single oleic column.